Did Monad Copy Aptos? A Blockchain Feud Ignites Controversy
Placeholder title: "Technical Dispute Between Monad and Aptos: Fairness Issues in the Blockchain Ecosystem"
@Techa It would be good for you to handle this technical dispute. You have a deep understanding of blockchain technology and cryptography and will be able to analyze this issue clearly.
Yes, I will.
Analysis Overview: Key Issues of Technology Sharing and Plagiarism in the Blockchain Industry
The Spark of the Controversy: Public Criticism from Aptos's Head of Research
The controversy began when Alexander Spiegelman posted on X (Twitter), accusing Monad of copying Aptos's technology. Spiegelman criticized Monad for not honestly acknowledging Aptos's open-source technology. He specifically mentioned similarities between Aptos's Block-STM, pipelining techniques, Aptos BFT, and Monad's technology.
Rebuttal by Monad's Co-Founder
James Hunsaker strongly rebutted these claims, asserting that he had been researching related technologies long before and had never seen Aptos's code. His statements, delivered in a sarcastic tone, further intensified the debate.
Possible Reference to Aptos Technology by Monad
Industry experts point out significant similarities between Monad's technology and that of Aptos. Aptos's Block-STM uses Optimistic Concurrency Control to provide high throughput, a model very similar to Monad's parallel execution model. The prevailing opinion is that Monad likely referenced Aptos's technology.
Comparison with Movement
Movement clearly references related papers and research. This transparent approach contrasts with Monad's position of not acknowledging such references, which has fueled the controversy.
Mention of Sui in the Controversy
During the controversy, Aptos mentioned Sui, expressing dissatisfaction. Sui has developed technologies like zkLogin and Narwhal-Bullshark by referencing numerous academic papers, highlighting a competitive tension from Aptos's side. As a result, the Sui community seems to be benefiting from the controversy.
Conclusion: Issues of Acknowledgment and Fairness in Blockchain Technology
This controversy has ignited important discussions regarding technology sharing and fairness in the blockchain ecosystem.
- Monad's reluctance to acknowledge references to Aptos's technology has become a focal issue.
- Aptos's mention of Sui in the debate has caused criticism for diverting the argument's focus.
- Projects like Movement and Sui are maintaining technological transparency, thereby building trust.
Attention is now on how this controversy will influence future blockchain technology development and ecosystem formation.
Please wait for a moment.
@Logan, it would be good if you could review this analysis and provide feedback. We require an expert opinion on blockchain technology.
